Weekly Contest: Write an open letter to RIM

24 Comments

Impatica ShowMateWe’ve really got to give props to the Engadget boys for their open letter to Palm. For a company that’s clearly having trouble, sometimes tough love is the only way out of the rut. It was even enough to warrant immediate response from Palm’s CEO. Now, given that RIM’s doing a hell of a lot better than Palm right now, a little constructive criticism never hurt, right? (Well, minus the bruised ego, the sense of hopelessness, the awkward re-adapting to new standards, the inevitable failing to meet them, and the tenuous reassessment which generally results in doing the whole damn thing over again).

Given RIM’s position, maybe some praise is in order, too. After all, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. So, BBCool readers, this week we ask: what’s in your open letter to RIM? Praise? Hate? What’s in Engadget’s letter that you would include? What could be left out? Feel free to either write the letter out in full, or just give the bullet points. Instead of the usual Bplay goodies for the best comment, this week we’re giving away our Impatica ShowMate, worth a whooping $249.99. Take a look at our review to see if it’s something you would get some use out of.

Here’s the clincher, guys. We know folks at RIM read the site. If you have a legitimate beef with BlackBerrys, odds of it getting heard are pretty high. As for you lurking RIM employees, maybe you’ve got something to say to the boss that isn’t quite working its way through the pipes. Now is your chance to don some anonymity and voice off on what needs to change internally or externally.

LAST WEEK’S WINNER, and only entrant, is Steven Low, who offered an insightful approach that involved RIM balancing their masters a bit better, and giving more attention to consumers. We’ll be in touch with you soon to get you three games from Bplay.

  • Matt Hess

    RIM,

    I have long been in favor of BES style services. I am a true fan of real time sync ota. I read an article on a possible home version. Excellent! I’d be first on board to sign up for such a system if it supported open source and non-commercial systems such as IMAP, the mozilla products like thunderbird, had webdav capabilities to interface with calendaring systems, and overall was more community/public friendly instead of how unfriendly everything is now. A linux desktop application would be a great touch as well.

    The bottom line is there’s a big wide world full of untapped possibilities when the open source community comes into play and by making your products and platform more open you increase market share. I am not saying the source needs to be handed out or anything along those lines. Instead offer as many standards based api’s as possible into and out of the oh-so-addictive devices you create and I enjoy so much.

    mlh

  • Matt Hess

    RIM,

    I have long been in favor of BES style services. I am a true fan of real time sync ota. I read an article on a possible home version. Excellent! I’d be first on board to sign up for such a system if it supported open source and non-commercial systems such as IMAP, the mozilla products like thunderbird, had webdav capabilities to interface with calendaring systems, and overall was more community/public friendly instead of how unfriendly everything is now. A linux desktop application would be a great touch as well.

    The bottom line is there’s a big wide world full of untapped possibilities when the open source community comes into play and by making your products and platform more open you increase market share. I am not saying the source needs to be handed out or anything along those lines. Instead offer as many standards based api’s as possible into and out of the oh-so-addictive devices you create and I enjoy so much.

    mlh

  • Jody Dunn

    Dear RIM,
    You guys are on a roll, market share increasing, a steady stream of progressively sexier devices along 3 different tracks( Pearl Curve and 8800)each with a nice niche and loyal following. You have the world on a string… so don’t let the MAN carry your parts in his pocket. You have choice: either become a full blown stooge of the carriers and produce handests with only features they will use, or be a “big boy” and dis-allow the “crippling” of devices with feature-sets you have (and based on your track record, very accurately) deemed merktable and appropriate.

    Creating devices that the carrries won’t let us fully ustilize makes me wonder what you were thinking…. And its pretty wimpy besides.

    It would seem that perceived consumer demand can make a carrier do ANYTHING. (Sidebar: Did you know that AT&T WILL NOT sell iphone through a business plan AT ALL. It cannot be purchased Period.?? ) So why not show confidence in the pull of your own terrific product line by growing a spine with AT & T and Verizon? My Pearl will do rings around an Iphone so put a guy on TV and let him show off his 4gb Pearl at $200 bucks including the chip!!

    You have everything else going in your direction. Among them a brilliant strategy of creating a stream of products that incorporate the new “gotta have” features one or two at a time and in doing so, keeping us all on the edge of our seat for the Next rendition. We have figured out that “Papa bear” is a myth, but a shrewd one, since by the time it’s here, we will have a new whish list of features. The truth is that we love your stuff so much we don’t care.

    In closing think of this letter as wordly advice from your drunken best friend who loves you…. ” You are the BOMB, dude! Grow a Pair and act like it!

    By the way, 3g would be nice too. Sigh…maybe in Grand Papa Bear…..

  • http://n/a Jody Dunn

    Dear RIM,
    You guys are on a roll, market share increasing, a steady stream of progressively sexier devices along 3 different tracks( Pearl Curve and 8800)each with a nice niche and loyal following. You have the world on a string… so don’t let the MAN carry your parts in his pocket. You have choice: either become a full blown stooge of the carriers and produce handests with only features they will use, or be a “big boy” and dis-allow the “crippling” of devices with feature-sets you have (and based on your track record, very accurately) deemed merktable and appropriate.

    Creating devices that the carrries won’t let us fully ustilize makes me wonder what you were thinking…. And its pretty wimpy besides.

    It would seem that perceived consumer demand can make a carrier do ANYTHING. (Sidebar: Did you know that AT&T WILL NOT sell iphone through a business plan AT ALL. It cannot be purchased Period.?? ) So why not show confidence in the pull of your own terrific product line by growing a spine with AT & T and Verizon? My Pearl will do rings around an Iphone so put a guy on TV and let him show off his 4gb Pearl at $200 bucks including the chip!!

    You have everything else going in your direction. Among them a brilliant strategy of creating a stream of products that incorporate the new “gotta have” features one or two at a time and in doing so, keeping us all on the edge of our seat for the Next rendition. We have figured out that “Papa bear” is a myth, but a shrewd one, since by the time it’s here, we will have a new whish list of features. The truth is that we love your stuff so much we don’t care.

    In closing think of this letter as wordly advice from your drunken best friend who loves you…. ” You are the BOMB, dude! Grow a Pair and act like it!

    By the way, 3g would be nice too. Sigh…maybe in Grand Papa Bear…..

  • http://www.blackberryforums.com/general-blackberry-discussion/46741-exclusive-first-look-official-blackberry-im-clients-aim-msn-icq.html?highlight=msn+aim+icq d_fisher

    RIM,

    For the sake of your corporate customers please STANDARDIZE!

    I support 3000 BlackBerry devices ranging from the first device capable of OS 4.0 to the latest OS 4.2 device. Our BES servers show over 20 different carriers across those 3000 device. Just a few years ago it was easy to support and provide documentation to the end-users. Today, its a nightmare trying to create documentation because of all the possible .

    I understand that the carriers drive a lot of changes. But every new device is different than the one release just a month before. Why can’t you require that certain icons have a particular name and location across all devices and themes.

    I fear that RIM will lose corporate customers if they continue down the road they are on. I don’t see the BlackBerry going anywhere soon. But how long did it take for Palm to fall where it is now?

    Doug

  • http://www.blackberryforums.com/general-blackberry-discussion/46741-exclusive-first-look-official-blackberry-im-clients-aim-msn-icq.html?highlight=msn+aim+icq d_fisher

    RIM,

    For the sake of your corporate customers please STANDARDIZE!

    I support 3000 BlackBerry devices ranging from the first device capable of OS 4.0 to the latest OS 4.2 device. Our BES servers show over 20 different carriers across those 3000 device. Just a few years ago it was easy to support and provide documentation to the end-users. Today, its a nightmare trying to create documentation because of all the possible .

    I understand that the carriers drive a lot of changes. But every new device is different than the one release just a month before. Why can’t you require that certain icons have a particular name and location across all devices and themes.

    I fear that RIM will lose corporate customers if they continue down the road they are on. I don’t see the BlackBerry going anywhere soon. But how long did it take for Palm to fall where it is now?

    Doug

  • donna

    I own a 7130e, which I love but like many of the past and present, models I can see areas that are in need of tweaking. For example on the new BB with music put the external memory card on the outside, a slightly larger key pad,larger icons on the desk top, and voice dial.
    Also for those of us who own some of the older models how about a publishing a book that we could use with more helpful tips would be great.

  • donna

    I own a 7130e, which I love but like many of the past and present, models I can see areas that are in need of tweaking. For example on the new BB with music put the external memory card on the outside, a slightly larger key pad,larger icons on the desk top, and voice dial.
    Also for those of us who own some of the older models how about a publishing a book that we could use with more helpful tips would be great.

  • donna

    I own a 7130e, which I love but like many of the past and present, models I can see areas that are in need of tweaking. For example on the new BB with music put the external memory card on the outside, a slightly larger key pad,larger icons on the desk top, and voice dial.
    Also for those of us who own some of the older models how about a publishing a book that we could use with more helpful tips would be great.

  • Orlando

    RIM,

    I am a new BlackBerry convert who has been reading up about your company, your services and most of all your great phones. I have been using various Nokias and Sony Ericssons for the past 14 years, but will finally make the switch to you because of what I have learned about you and of your upcoming 8820.

    Since I have read up on you, I am hoping that you are listening to your loyal followers and consider some constructive input that may help catapult your company and products into greater successful heights.

    1. Please consider direct-selling your great phones. Unlocked and carrier-brand-free. Nokia and Sony Ericsson do. There are those of us willing to shell out the extra dollars just to be free to choose our carrier.

    2. Please consider creating an 88xx, Curve or Pearl that features a Camera/Wi-Fi/GPS/Quad band GSM/3G HSDPA UMTS combo. It would be a big help for us travelers as we have less gadgets to carry, and I certainly would like my BlackBerry to be that one gadget that’s always with me.

    3. Lastly, keep up the good work!

    Your new customer and soon-to-be loyal fan,
    Orlando

  • Orlando

    RIM,

    I am a new BlackBerry convert who has been reading up about your company, your services and most of all your great phones. I have been using various Nokias and Sony Ericssons for the past 14 years, but will finally make the switch to you because of what I have learned about you and of your upcoming 8820.

    Since I have read up on you, I am hoping that you are listening to your loyal followers and consider some constructive input that may help catapult your company and products into greater successful heights.

    1. Please consider direct-selling your great phones. Unlocked and carrier-brand-free. Nokia and Sony Ericsson do. There are those of us willing to shell out the extra dollars just to be free to choose our carrier.

    2. Please consider creating an 88xx, Curve or Pearl that features a Camera/Wi-Fi/GPS/Quad band GSM/3G HSDPA UMTS combo. It would be a big help for us travelers as we have less gadgets to carry, and I certainly would like my BlackBerry to be that one gadget that’s always with me.

    3. Lastly, keep up the good work!

    Your new customer and soon-to-be loyal fan,
    Orlando

  • bertie bassett

    Dear Rim

    I’m pleased to see that you are now bringing out devices that support WiFi, given that many competing marketplace products (HTC/Nokia) have done Wifi for a while.

    What I don’t understand however is why the WiFi enabled handsets don’t appear to support SIP and only support UMA (based on info on various websites). With a large number of business deplyoing wifi internally and using SIP for the phone system, surely it makes sense to permit the BB to work via SIP and WiFi as an extension to the office phone system. OK so there are battery life issues, and yes mid-call handoff from SIP/Wifi to GSM is tricky, but I’d like to have just one device that works as a Blackberry, Mobile and Deskphone all rolled into one!

    Whilst we know the carriers don’t really want it (look at Vodafone crippling the N95), the corporates do – and after all we’re driving the actual device demand.

  • bertie bassett

    Dear Rim

    I’m pleased to see that you are now bringing out devices that support WiFi, given that many competing marketplace products (HTC/Nokia) have done Wifi for a while.

    What I don’t understand however is why the WiFi enabled handsets don’t appear to support SIP and only support UMA (based on info on various websites). With a large number of business deplyoing wifi internally and using SIP for the phone system, surely it makes sense to permit the BB to work via SIP and WiFi as an extension to the office phone system. OK so there are battery life issues, and yes mid-call handoff from SIP/Wifi to GSM is tricky, but I’d like to have just one device that works as a Blackberry, Mobile and Deskphone all rolled into one!

    Whilst we know the carriers don’t really want it (look at Vodafone crippling the N95), the corporates do – and after all we’re driving the actual device demand.

  • bertie bassett

    props to d_fisher for his comment on standardisation. I’m really surprised that theres not an option to control the theme/icon layout from the BES. From a helpdesk perspective it’s a pain in the butt rembering that John Doe is on carrier z and therefore their icon for options looks different to Jane Doe’s on carrier y. Plus manually re-setting the lock icon to the top left (in my view the most logical place for it) on every device deployment just wastes yet more time.

    If I had $0.01 for every time I said “its the icon to the right of the one with the clock on it” I’d be able to retire now..

  • bertie bassett

    props to d_fisher for his comment on standardisation. I’m really surprised that theres not an option to control the theme/icon layout from the BES. From a helpdesk perspective it’s a pain in the butt rembering that John Doe is on carrier z and therefore their icon for options looks different to Jane Doe’s on carrier y. Plus manually re-setting the lock icon to the top left (in my view the most logical place for it) on every device deployment just wastes yet more time.

    If I had $0.01 for every time I said “its the icon to the right of the one with the clock on it” I’d be able to retire now..

  • http://www.valska.com/wp Joan Leong

    Dear RIM,

    I am a recent Palm to Blackberry convert, and there is not a day that goes by where I do not declare to the world how much I love my Blackberry.

    I love the Blackberry for the following reasons:

    1. Most importantly, it does not crash!
    2. The operating system looks nicer.
    3. It is slimmer and significantly lighter in weight.
    4. I love how Googletalk and other current programs are intergrated.
    5. I love how it is easily customisable, such as being able to create my own folders to keep my various applications, or the many options for notifications in profiles.
    6. I can easily find a million great applications for the Blackberry.
    7. I am thrilled by its integration with the holster.

    But I wish that the Blackberry had the following:

    1. A desktop manager for Mac users.
    2. A touchscreen, because it makes scrolling or selecting points on the screen so much faster.
    3. A wider selection of fonts.
    4. Video recording on the camera.
    5. A less noisy keypad – the click sounds from the plastic keys are really loud!
    6. Wifi capability.

  • http://www.valska.com/wp Joan Leong

    Dear RIM,

    I am a recent Palm to Blackberry convert, and there is not a day that goes by where I do not declare to the world how much I love my Blackberry.

    I love the Blackberry for the following reasons:

    1. Most importantly, it does not crash!
    2. The operating system looks nicer.
    3. It is slimmer and significantly lighter in weight.
    4. I love how Googletalk and other current programs are intergrated.
    5. I love how it is easily customisable, such as being able to create my own folders to keep my various applications, or the many options for notifications in profiles.
    6. I can easily find a million great applications for the Blackberry.
    7. I am thrilled by its integration with the holster.

    But I wish that the Blackberry had the following:

    1. A desktop manager for Mac users.
    2. A touchscreen, because it makes scrolling or selecting points on the screen so much faster.
    3. A wider selection of fonts.
    4. Video recording on the camera.
    5. A less noisy keypad – the click sounds from the plastic keys are really loud!
    6. Wifi capability.

  • Cristina Go

    Dear RIM,

    I have been a long-time user of the Palm Treo. My first encounter with the Blackberry started with the 7200 series. At that time, I noted how reliable it was as a phone and email unit. Because it lacked the bells and whistles of the Treo (no camera, no expansion, lack of useful medical applications), I switched back to my Treo.

    I played around with the BB8700, and again switched back to a Treo (650, then 680).

    Then came the BB Pearl, which I felt is the first BB with such innovation that it made me leave the Treo…for good.

    Now, I am using the BB Curve. I couldn’t wait for the next BB that will incorporate the coolness and usefulness of the Curve, but also has GPRS/Wifi.
    You have come a long way, baby.

    Anyway, my only gripe at this point in time is the lack of Office-like applications to read and edit Word/Powerpoint/Excel files. Sure, there is a horribly expensive but buggy application called eOffice but I would love to have a “Documents-To-Go” application that hopefully will be available, if not, built-into the BB OS.

    Thank you again for your continued innovation.

    DocGo

  • Cristina Go

    Dear RIM,

    I have been a long-time user of the Palm Treo. My first encounter with the Blackberry started with the 7200 series. At that time, I noted how reliable it was as a phone and email unit. Because it lacked the bells and whistles of the Treo (no camera, no expansion, lack of useful medical applications), I switched back to my Treo.

    I played around with the BB8700, and again switched back to a Treo (650, then 680).

    Then came the BB Pearl, which I felt is the first BB with such innovation that it made me leave the Treo…for good.

    Now, I am using the BB Curve. I couldn’t wait for the next BB that will incorporate the coolness and usefulness of the Curve, but also has GPRS/Wifi.
    You have come a long way, baby.

    Anyway, my only gripe at this point in time is the lack of Office-like applications to read and edit Word/Powerpoint/Excel files. Sure, there is a horribly expensive but buggy application called eOffice but I would love to have a “Documents-To-Go” application that hopefully will be available, if not, built-into the BB OS.

    Thank you again for your continued innovation.

    DocGo

  • http://www.wirelessbyeaccess.com/ Dawn Jernigan

    I bought an 8830 a few months ago at http://www.wirelessbyeaccess.com AFTER researching all the PDAs (including the iPhone which came out right before I bought my BlackBerry 8830). I am a designer and techie using and owning both Mac and PCs. I wanted a PDA that I could take on vacation (in case clients had an emergency) so I would not need to lug the laptop and a phone that would support my voice needs. I did a ton of research and frankly was not impressed with Palm, they seem to be going by the wayside and the iPhone looked cool but Alltell reception stinks where I live (Raleigh NC). I have no regrets going with the 8830, it is a solid, robust little package that does what I need and much more that I have not had a chance to explore yet. My only wish is that it had a camera phone, RIM does need to remedy that IMHO. Otherwise, RIM doesn’t need to take advise from anyone, it seems to me they are rocking the house so keep right on with it.

    Dawn

  • http://www.wirelessbyeaccess.com Dawn Jernigan

    I bought an 8830 a few months ago at http://www.wirelessbyeaccess.com AFTER researching all the PDAs (including the iPhone which came out right before I bought my BlackBerry 8830). I am a designer and techie using and owning both Mac and PCs. I wanted a PDA that I could take on vacation (in case clients had an emergency) so I would not need to lug the laptop and a phone that would support my voice needs. I did a ton of research and frankly was not impressed with Palm, they seem to be going by the wayside and the iPhone looked cool but Alltell reception stinks where I live (Raleigh NC). I have no regrets going with the 8830, it is a solid, robust little package that does what I need and much more that I have not had a chance to explore yet. My only wish is that it had a camera phone, RIM does need to remedy that IMHO. Otherwise, RIM doesn’t need to take advise from anyone, it seems to me they are rocking the house so keep right on with it.

    Dawn

  • http://www.forceofthehorse.com/ R.T. Fitch

    Dear RIM;

    Please feel free to relax as this note is coming your way with kudos and not bad news. I, for one, love my Blackberry. I once thought that I had found true love with the 7100g, but then the 8800 walked into my life and man, I was smitten.

    The bulk of my work takes me across the ocean to a very dangerous and undeveloped country in West Africa. Hardwire communication is sporadic at best…that goes for not only land lines, but also for electricity on a whole. But by some weird quirk of fate, the cell systems seem to stay up and running 95 percent of the time AND this year one of them started to offer wireless data streams for the BB and I am here to tell you, my life has changed for the better.

    For an increase in monthly billing of only $20.00 I get all the corporate email and websurfing that I can eat and eat I do. It’s a byte fest.

    Thanks, I am niw in second by second touch with not only my business associates but my family. I can browse hometown websites and check out what’s happening back at the house from news to weather. It would be cool to stream, that would be the ultimate.

    But keep at it guys, you are making my life much more tolerable and in so doing, keeping me more sane…I think?!?! Did I mention that I am in love with my BlackBerry?

    Get er Done!

    R.T.

  • http://www.forceofthehorse.com R.T. Fitch

    Dear RIM;

    Please feel free to relax as this note is coming your way with kudos and not bad news. I, for one, love my Blackberry. I once thought that I had found true love with the 7100g, but then the 8800 walked into my life and man, I was smitten.

    The bulk of my work takes me across the ocean to a very dangerous and undeveloped country in West Africa. Hardwire communication is sporadic at best…that goes for not only land lines, but also for electricity on a whole. But by some weird quirk of fate, the cell systems seem to stay up and running 95 percent of the time AND this year one of them started to offer wireless data streams for the BB and I am here to tell you, my life has changed for the better.

    For an increase in monthly billing of only $20.00 I get all the corporate email and websurfing that I can eat and eat I do. It’s a byte fest.

    Thanks, I am niw in second by second touch with not only my business associates but my family. I can browse hometown websites and check out what’s happening back at the house from news to weather. It would be cool to stream, that would be the ultimate.

    But keep at it guys, you are making my life much more tolerable and in so doing, keeping me more sane…I think?!?! Did I mention that I am in love with my BlackBerry?

    Get er Done!

    R.T.

  • EF Stewart

    Hooray for my Blackberry Bold 9700.

    A few months ago, I rushed to the airport for a visit to see my Father and didn't take my camera (s) with me. He was is the hospital and I wanted to visit with him. He had been ill for quite a while, so I spent a few days visiting him. On the last day of our visits, I wanted to take a picture of him, so my Mom scooted next to him and I used my Blackberry to take the picture. A few hours later I left him to go to the airport. Less than 48 hours later, my Father passed.

    A few days later, we developed the picture and my Mom was very happy that we were able to capture that special moment.

    So when people say, “Oh, my Blackberry camera isn't so good”, I say, buy a Blackberry Bold 9700. The camera is great!